Connect with us

Baseball

To Deal Or Not To Deal: Joba Chamberlain for Scott Downs?

It’s no secret the New York Yankees and GM Brian Cashman would like to improve the teams pitching. After missing out of top of the line starters Cliff Lee and Dan Haren, the attention is likely moved to acquiring bullpen help.

It’s no secret the New York Yankees and GM Brian Cashman would like to improve the teams pitching. After missing out of top of the line starters Cliff Lee and Dan Haren, the attention is likely moved to acquiring bullpen help.

Can a deal be worked out before the trade deadline this Saturday?

There have been a number of names thrown around of late. There was talk of the Yankees trying to acquire closer Joakim Soria from the Kansas City Royals. That deal would solve the Yankees bullpen problems immediately as well as in the future, but it seems unlikely.

Of the players known to be available, the best bullpen arm is likely Scott Downs of the Toronto Blue Jays. Toronto GM Alex Anthopoulos knows he has the best reliever available and is so far taking advantage of that. He is asking for some big names and big prospects in return for Downs.

According to the New York Post, Toronto has asked for Joba Chamberlain or Jesus Montero in return for Downs.

Now, I highly doubt the Yankees would give up Joba or Montero for a two to three month rental on Downs. Would you?

With Joba Chamberlain struggling this season in the eight inning role and lefty Damaso Marte on the disabled list, the Yankees are in the market for relief help including a lefty specialist.

Downs could help in both areas. He could be used as a specialist against left handed batters or as a seventh or eight inning guy. But at what cost? Is he worth giving up Joba or top prospect Jesus Montero? I don’t think so.

I’d be happy to acquire Downs at a lower cost. As the trade deadline gets closer, the Blue Jays will have to decide between lowering their asking price or keeping Downs and losing him via free agency.

I am one of the people willing to part ways with Joba Chamberlain, but not for Scott Downs.

Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

More in Baseball