Baseball Should the National League adopt a designated hitter? by Chris Passarelli June 12, 2018 It’s very fair to say that if Masahiro Tanaka had not gotten hurt during the Subway Series this weekend while running the bases, that we wouldn’t be having this conversation. But alas, here we are having this conversation, because he did, straining his hamstring running home in a pivotal matchup between the two cross-town rivals. Tanaka will be out at least 10 days after being put on the DL, and it’s happened to the Yankees before, losing Chien-Ming Wang to an identical injury. Unfortunately for Wang, he never recovered, so hopefully this cautionary tale ends differently for Tanaka. The tale of the designated hitter was started in 1967 when Ron Bloomberg of the Yankees became the very first to take on the role in the American League. The rule was adopted and the two leagues essentially played two different styles of baseball, even in modern times. The managerial decisions are different, the plate approach is different, and the way a team is even constructed is different between the American and National leagues. It may be a cute ode to the baseball days of old with the pitchers hitting and once in a blue moon getting a hit, but in my opinion it’s dumb because the risk of injury is much higher than the reward. There have been many pitchers who have gotten hurt batting or running the bases, some in our own backyard. For the Mets, they lost Jacob deGrom because of the rule, and for the Yankees they’ve lost two aces so far, Chien-Ming Wang for an extended period of time and Masahiro Tanaka for an unknown amount of time. Regardless of the severity of the injury, there have been too many instances where a pitcher acting like a position player has gone wrong. Tanaka is just another notch in the belt that is pitchers being unprepared to hit. He is a shining example of a pitcher who doesn’t know how to hit, run, or really do anything else on the baseball diamond but pitch. It’s not his fault, but the risk of injury is very high considering he doesn’t have a clue what he’s doing out there. Sure you get some great moments (as seen below) like Bartolo Colon crushing a home run. However, just from a statistical standpoint the National League rule of hitting pitchers doesn’t make sense. If a pitcher gets a hit once every ten or eleven at bars how much does that really help out the team. In interleague play, most of the pitchers in the American League flail at the ball, using their bat more as a sword than a hitting tool. There are very few pitchers who have ever mastered the art of hitting, because they’re not supposed to. They are pitchers, not hitters. It may sound like I’m complaining but it just doesn’t make any sense why the leagues have adopted two different rules. If pitchers are going to hit, at least make it a standard for both the American and National leagues. If not, adopt a universal designated hitter rule. It will eliminate pointless at bats, the risk for injury, and some of the convoluted decisions a manager has to make with double switches, replacing a batting pitcher, etc. The pitcher being able to hit is a great novelty for baseball, but it doesn’t mean all that much when it has little impact on the game other than from a strategy standpoint. Baseball purists will yell that this is how it’s always been for baseball and it should remain because of that notion, but how many things over the past few years have changed to modernize the game of baseball? Ty Cobb would be rolling over in his grave if he saw that catches can no longer be bowled over or there’s a replay for any close play at the plate. It’s asinine to think that this league can’t adapt. Will this point of view actually change anything in baseball? Probably not, but it’s worth a shot. We can’t have our star pitchers getting hurt for absolutely no reason other than trying to preserve some old baseball rules. The risk is not worth the reward, and it’s time for a change. You’re on the clock Commish. Post Views: 2,755 The following two tabs change content below.BioLatest Posts Chris Passarelli Football Editor - Hockey Editor - New York Islanders Lead Writer - New York Lizards Lead Writer - UConn Football Lead Writer Latest posts by Chris Passarelli (see all) NFL Network to Premiere ‘The Top 100 Players of 2020’ on July 26 - July 22, 2020 The ‘Toilet Bowl’ may be coming to Western New York - July 16, 2020 Bigger is Better; SoFi Stadium Completes Largest Videoboard in Sports - July 1, 2020 Smoltz, Vrabel and Brown talk American Century Championship and Everything in Between - June 30, 2020 Related TopicsAmerican LeagueBartolo ColonChien-Ming WangDesignated hitterJacob deGromMajor League BaseballMasahiro TanakaNational LeagueNew York MetsNew York YankeesRob Manfred 1 Comment You must be logged in to post a comment Login Leave a Reply Cancel replyYou must be logged in to post a comment. Newsletter Subscription Can't Miss Posts! Women in Sports: NHL Network Host, Jackie Redmond by Nicholas Durst | posted on March 4, 2019 From Paramus High School to CBS Sports, Spero Dedes is making waves in sports broadcasting by Sunil Sunder Raj | posted on October 27, 2020 Lochte, Dressel and Ledecky all Chasing Gold at 2021 Tokyo Olympics by Anthony Paradiso | posted on April 18, 2021 Women in Sports: Podcast Host, New York Riptide Sideline Reporter, Dani Wexelman by Luke Porco | posted on March 3, 2020 You Know I’m Right, Episode 109: The Athletic’s Marc Carig (Audio/Video) by Nicholas Durst | posted on April 19, 2021 More in Baseball You Know I’m Right, Episode 112: New York Jets’ Insider Brian Costello (Audio/Video) On the 112th episode of You Know I’m Right, Nick Durst and Joe Calabrese are joined by... You Know I’m Right, Episode 109: The Athletic’s Marc Carig (Audio/Video) On the 109th episode of You Know I’m Right, Nick Durst and Joe Calabrese are joined by... You Know I’m Right, Episode 108: WFAN’s Sweeny Murti (Audio/Video) On the 108th episode of You Know I’m Right, Nick Durst and Joe Calabrese are joined by... You Know I’m Right, Episode 107: New York Post’s Columnist Mike Vaccaro (Audio/Video) On the 107th episode of You Know I’m Right, Nick Durst and Joe Calabrese are joined by... Todd Frazier reaping benefits for both Mets and Yankees Patriots Edge Revolution 2-1